Purpose Evaluating medical school selection tools is vital for evidence-based student selection. With previous reviews revealing knowledge gaps, this meta-analysis offers insights into the effectiveness of these selection tools.
Methods A systematic review and meta-analysis were conducted applying the following criteria: peer-reviewed articles available in English, published from 2010 and which include empirical data linking performance in selection tools with assessment and dropout outcomes of undergraduate entry medical programs. Systematic reviews, meta-analyses, general opinion pieces, or commentaries were excluded. Effect sizes (ESs) of the predictability of academic and clinical performance within and by the end of the medicine program were extracted, and the pooled ESs were presented.
Results Sixty-seven out of 2,212 articles were included, which yielded 236 ESs. Previous academic achievement predicted medical program academic performance (Cohen’s d=0.697 in early program; 0.619 in end of program) and clinical exams (0.545 in end of program). Within aptitude tests, verbal reasoning and quantitative reasoning predicted academic achievement in the early program and in the last years (0.704 & 0.643, respectively). Overall aptitude tests predicted academic achievement in both the early and last years (0.550 & 0.371, respectively). Neither panel interviews, multiple mini-interviews, nor situational judgement tests (SJT) yielded statistically significant pooled ES.
Conclusion Current evidence suggests that learning outcomes are predicted by previous academic achievement and aptitude tests. The predictive value of SJT and topics such as selection algorithms, features of interview (e.g., content of the questions) and the way the interviewers’ reports are used, warrant further research.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Notice of Retraction and Replacement: Insights into undergraduate medical student selection tools: a systematic review and meta-analysis Pin-Hsiang Huang, Arash Arianpoor, Silas Taylor, Jenzel Gonzales, Boaz Shulruf Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions.2024; 21: 41. CrossRef
Purpose This study aimed to explore how the grading system affected medical students’ academic performance based on their perceptions of the learning environment and intrinsic motivation in the context of changing from norm-referenced A–F grading to criterion-referenced honors/pass/fail grading.
Methods The study involved 238 second-year medical students from 2014 (n=127, A–F grading) and 2015 (n=111, honors/pass/fail grading) at Yonsei University College of Medicine in Korea. Scores on the Dundee Ready Education Environment Measure, the Academic Motivation Scale, and the Basic Medical Science Examination were used to measure overall learning environment perceptions, intrinsic motivation, and academic performance, respectively. Serial mediation analysis was conducted to examine the pathways between the grading system and academic performance, focusing on the mediating roles of student perceptions and intrinsic motivation.
Results The honors/pass/fail grading class students reported more positive perceptions of the learning environment, higher intrinsic motivation, and better academic performance than the A–F grading class students. Mediation analysis demonstrated a serial mediation effect between the grading system and academic performance through learning environment perceptions and intrinsic motivation. Student perceptions and intrinsic motivation did not independently mediate the relationship between the grading system and performance.
Conclusion Reducing the number of grades and eliminating rank-based grading might have created an affirming learning environment that fulfills basic psychological needs and reinforces the intrinsic motivation linked to academic performance. The cumulative effect of these 2 mediators suggests that a comprehensive approach should be used to understand student performance.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Erratum: Impact of a change from A–F grading to honors/pass/fail grading on academic performance at Yonsei University College of Medicine in Korea: a cross-sectional serial mediation analysis
Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions.2024; 21: 35. CrossRef
Purpose Rehabilitation science programs utilize cognitive and non-cognitive factors to select students who can complete the didactic and clinical portions of the program and pass the licensure exam. Cognitive factors such a prior grade point average and standardized test scores are known to be predictive of academic performance, but the relationship of non-cognitive factors and performance is less clear. The purpose of this systematic review was to explore the relationship of non-cognitive factors to academic and clinical performance in rehabilitation science programs.
Methods A search of 7 databases was conducted using the following eligibility criteria: graduate programs in physical therapy (PT), occupational therapy, speech-language pathology, United States-based programs, measurement of at least 1 non-cognitive factor, measurement of academic and/or clinical performance, and quantitative reporting of results. Articles were screened by title, abstract, and full text, and data were extracted.
Results After the comprehensive screening, 21 articles were included in the review. Seventy-six percent of studies occurred in PT students. Grit, self-efficacy, emotional intelligence, and stress were the most commonly studied factors. Only self-efficacy, emotional intelligence, and personality traits were examined in clinical and academic contexts. The results were mixed for all non-cognitive factors. Higher grit and self-efficacy tended to be associated with better performance, while stress was generally associated with worse outcomes.
Conclusion No single non-cognitive factor was consistently related to clinical or academic performance in rehabilitation science students. There is insufficient evidence currently to recommend the evaluation of a specific non-cognitive factor for admissions decisions.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Examining the Mediating Role of Grit and Self‐Efficacy in the Association Between Growth Mindset and Job Satisfaction in a Sample of Chinese Nurses Xiaoyan Zhang, Chen Qiu, Xiaolin Li, Aniruddha Shekara, Xueling Suo, Song Wang, De-Chih Lee Journal of Nursing Management.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Predicting performance in a doctor of physical therapy gross anatomy course based on an exploratory factor analysis of the anatomical self‐efficacy instrument Kelly Reynolds, Shani Mueller, Maggie Horn Anatomical Sciences Education.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
The Relationship between Cognitive Factors and Noncognitive Factors, Including Grit, and NBCOT® Exam Performance Anne H. Zachry, Stephanie Lancaster, Amy Hall, April Hilsdon Occupational Therapy In Health Care.2024; : 1. CrossRef
Academic Coaching in Entry-level Doctor of Physical Therapy Education Kayla Black, Jessica Feda, Breanna Reynolds, Guillermo Cutrone, Kendra Gagnon Journal of Physical Therapy Education.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Basic components of a personal resource determining a personified subject of activity: The impact on university students’ academic achievement Vera Stepanovna Tretyakova, Anastasia Evgenievna Kaigorodova, Anton Alexandrovich Sharov, Evald Friedrichovich Zeer Science for Education Today.2024; 14(2): 206. CrossRef
Comparison of 2 Methods of Debriefing for Learning of Interprofessional Handoff Skills Julie Ronnebaum, Chunfa Jie, Kristina Salazar Journal of Acute Care Physical Therapy.2023; 14(1): 18. CrossRef
Investigating Latent Interactions between Students’ Affective Cognition and Learning Performance: Meta-Analysis of Affective and Cognitive Factors Jian Li, Eryong Xue, Chenchang Li, Yunshu He Behavioral Sciences.2023; 13(7): 555. CrossRef
Relationship between digital capabilities and academic performance: the mediating effect of self-efficacy Rasha Kadri Ibrahim, Aisha Namshan Aldawsari BMC Nursing.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
The study of the personification of the actor as a psychological phenomenon Vera Stepanovna Tretyakova, Anastasia Evgenievna Kaigorodova, Anton Alexandrovich Sharov, Evald Friedrichovich Zeer Science for Education Today.2023; 13(3): 101. CrossRef
Grouping of academic achievements’ predictors in Russian current psychological and pedagogical studies Roman A. Dormidontov Psychological-Pedagogical Journal GAUDEAMUS.2022; (4): 18. CrossRef
Purpose This study examined how students’ academic performance changed after undergoing a transition to online learning during the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, based on the test results of 16 integrated courses conducted in 3 semesters at Hanyang University College of Medicine in Korea.
Methods For the 16 required courses that formed an integrated system-based curriculum running for 3 semesters, the major examinations’ raw scores were collected for each student. Percent-correct scores were used in the subsequent analysis. We used the t-test to compare grades between 2019 and 2020, and the Cohen D was calculated as a measure of effect size. The correlation of scores between courses was calculated using Pearson correlation coefficients.
Results There was a significant decrease in scores in 2020 for 10 courses (62.5%). While most of the integrated system-based curriculum test scores showed strong correlations, with coefficients of 0.6 or higher in both 2019 and 2020, the correlation coefficients were generally higher in 2020. When students were divided into low, middle, and high achievement groups, low-achieving students consistently showed declining test scores in all 3 semesters.
Conclusion Our findings suggest that the transition to online classes due to COVID-19 has led to an overall decline in academic performance. This overall decline, which may occur when the curriculum is centered on recorded lectures, needs to be addressed. Further, medical schools need to consider establishing a support system for the academic development of low-achieving students.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Study delay during emergency remote teaching among students at Dutch universities: the role of students’ education satisfaction and academic wellbeing Manja Vollmann, Renée A. Scheepers, Femke Hilverda European Journal of Psychology of Education.2024; 39(3): 2849. CrossRef
Impact of the Covid-19 pandemic and ensuing online teaching on pre-clinical medical education Houman Goudarzi, Masahiro Onozawa, Makoto Takahashi BMC Medical Education.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Navigating the shift to online learning: student experiences of inclusivity, efficiency, and study efforts in Chile Grace Melo, Diego Monteza, Sandra Acosta Cogent Education.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
The effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on students' academic performance and mental health: An overview Shamim Al Aziz Lalin, Mufti Nadimul Quamar Ahmed, Shah Md Atiqul Haq Regional Science Policy & Practice.2024; 16(7): 100046. CrossRef
Student preferences over module design Joshua Fullard Discover Education.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Prevalence and associated factors of ADHD-like symptoms among
pharmacy students at Prince of Songkla University, Thailand in 2024: a
cross-sectional study Krittiya Rakchat, Saranan Eadcharoen, Amarawan Pentrakan The Ewha Medical Journal.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Moodle’s communicative instruments: The impact on students academic performance Alwaely Suad, Olga Tapalova, Anna Berestova, Svetlana Vlasova Innovations in Education and Teaching International.2024; : 1. CrossRef
Examining the factors influencing academic performance of medical technology students in e-learning: A questionnaire survey Ding-Ping Chen, Ai-Ling Hour, Kuo-Chien Tsao, Chung-Guei Huang, Wei-Tzu Lin, Fang-Ping Hsu, Jenny Wilkinson PLOS ONE.2024; 19(12): e0311528. CrossRef
The nationwide impact of COVID-19 on life support courses. A retrospective evaluation by Resuscitation Council UK C.J. Thorne, P.K. Kimani, S. Hampshire, I. Hamilton-Bower, S. Begum-Ali, A. Benson-Clarke, K. Couper, J. Yeung, A. Lockey, G.D. Perkins, J. Soar Resuscitation Plus.2023; 13: 100366. CrossRef
COVID-19 and Living Situation: Effects on University of Michigan Students During the 2020-2021 Academic Year Barbara Tan, Alyssa Cadez-Martin, Sarah Fox Fox, Samir Gadepalli University of Michigan Undergraduate Research Journal.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
How successful the online assessment techniques in distance learning have been, in contributing to academic achievements of management undergraduates? Hiruni Thathsarani, Dinushika Kaushalya Ariyananda, Chalani Jayakody, Kerthiga Manoharan, A.A.S.N Munasinghe, Nilmini Rathnayake Education and Information Technologies.2023; 28(11): 14091. CrossRef
Academic performance and mental health among Chinese middle and high school students after the lifting of COVID-19 restrictions Hong-Jun Song, Yun-Fei Mu, Cong Wang, Jia Cai, Zhong-Yue Deng, Ai-Ping Deng, Xue-Hua Huang, Xian-Dong Meng, Lan Zhang, Yi Huang, Wei Zhang, Wen-Wu Shen, Jin Chen, Bo Liu, Ru Gao, Jun-Shu Zhao, Mao-Sheng Ran Frontiers in Psychiatry.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
HOW DID ONLINE LEARNING AFFECT PHYSIOTHERAPY STUDENTS DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC? Muhammet Fatih BULUT, Aybüke Cansu KALKAN, Arzu GENÇ, Seher ÖZYÜREK SDÜ Tıp Fakültesi Dergisi.2023; 30(4): 652. CrossRef
The impact of asynchronous online anatomy teaching and smaller learning groups in the anatomy laboratory on medical students’ performance during the Covid‐19 pandemic Ming‐Fong Chang, Meng‐Lin Liao, June‐Horng Lue, Chi‐Chuan Yeh Anatomical Sciences Education.2022; 15(3): 476. CrossRef
Educational impact of an active learning session with 6-lead mobile electrocardiography on medical students’ knowledge of cardiovascular physiology during the COVID-19 pandemic in the United States: a survey-based observational study Alexandra Camille Greb, Emma Altieri, Irene Masini, Emily Helena Frisch, Milton Leon Greenberg Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions.2022; 19: 12. CrossRef
Coronavirus Disease 2019 Cases at Universities and Colleges in Seoul Metropolitan Area Young June Choe, Yun-Kyung Kim Journal of Korean Medical Science.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Purpose Learning to perform and document patient history taking and physical exam (H&P) entails a major component of the first year academic education of physician assistant (PA) students at Wayne State University, USA. The H&P is summative of multiple aspects of PA education, and students must master communication with patients and other health care providers. The objectives of this study were first, to determine if there was a correlation between scores on the Graduate Record Examination (GRE) component testing and scores on graded H&Ps. The second objective was to identify a correlation between proficiency with H&P documentation and academic and clinical year grade point average (GPA) and Physician Assistant National Certifying Exam (PANCE) score.
Methods Subjects included 147 PA students from Wayne State University from 2014–2016. PA students visited local hospitals or outpatient clinics during the academic year to perform and document patient H&Ps. Correlation between the H&P mean scores and GRE component scores, GPAs, and PANCE scores were analyzed.
Results The subjects were 26.5 years-old (+6.5) and 111 females (75.5%). There was no correlation between the GRE component score and the H&P mean score. The H&P score was positively correlated with GPA 1 (r=0.512, P<0.001), with GPA 2 (r=0.425, P<0.001) and with PANCE score (r=0.448, P<0.001).
Conclusion PA student skill with H&P documentation was positively related to academic performance score during PA school and achievement score on the PANCE at Wayne State University, USA.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
History-taking level and its influencing factors among nursing undergraduates based on the virtual standardized patient testing results: Cross sectional study Jingrong Du, Xiaowen Zhu, Juan Wang, Jing Zheng, Xiaomin Zhang, Ziwen Wang, Kun Li Nurse Education Today.2022; 111: 105312. CrossRef
A Decline in Black and Dermatology Physician Assistants Jameka McElroy-Brooklyn, Cynthia Faires Griffith Journal of Physician Assistant Education.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Purpose Different students may adopt different learning approaches: namely, deep and surface. This study aimed to characterize the learning strategies of medical students at Trinity School of Medicine and to explore potential correlations between deep learning approach and the students’ academic scores.
Methods The study was a questionnaire-based, cross-sectional, observational study. A total of 169 medical students in the basic science years of training were included in the study after giving informed consent. The Biggs’s Revised Two-Factor Study Process Questionnaire in paper form was distributed to subjects from January to November 2017. For statistical analyses, the Student t-test, 1-way analysis of variance followed by the post-hoc t-test, and the Pearson correlation test were used. The Cronbach alpha was used to test the internal consistency of the questionnaire.
Results Of the 169 subjects, 132 (response rate, 78.1%) completely filled out the questionnaires. The Cronbach alpha value for the items on the questionnaire was 0.8. The score for the deep learning approach was 29.4± 4.6, whereas the score for the surface approach was 24.3± 4.2, which was a significant difference (P< 0.05). A positive correlation was found between the deep learning approach and students’ academic performance (r= 0.197, P< 0.05, df= 130).
Conclusion Medical students in the basic science years at Trinity School of Medicine adopted the deep learning approach more than the surface approach. Likewise, students who were more inclined towards the deep learning approach scored significantly higher on academic tests.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Evaluating the Dynamics of Learning Approaches: A Systematic Review Investigating the Nexus Between Teaching Methods and Academic Performance in Medical and Dental Education Marlen A. Roehe, Carmen Trost, Julia S. Grundnig, Anahit Anvari-Pirsch, Anita Holzinger Educational Psychology Review.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Predictors of undergraduate occupational therapy students’ academic performance during the Covid-19 pandemic: A hierarchical regression analysis Ted Brown, Luke Robinson, Kate Gledhill, Mong-Lin Yu, Stephen Isbel, Craig Greber, Dave Parsons, Jamie Etherington Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy.2023; 30(4): 475. CrossRef
Student characteristics associated with dominant approaches to studying: Comparing a national and an international sample Mikkel M. Thørrisen, Gry Mørk, Lene A. Åsli, Astrid Gramstad, Linda Stigen, Trine A. Magne, Tove Carstensen, Susanne G. Johnson, Ted Brown, Hua B. Lim, Kenneth N. K. Fong, Tore Bonsaksen Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy.2022; 29(1): 13. CrossRef
Development and Preliminary Validation of the Physical Education-Study Process Questionnaire : Insights for Physical Education University Students Amayra Tannoubi, Noomen Guelmami, Tore Bonsaksen, Nasr Chalghaf, Fairouz Azaiez, Nicola Luigi Bragazzi Frontiers in Public Health.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
The Effect of Medical School Students' Study Approaches on Academic Achievement Zerrin GAMSIZKAN, Mehmet GAMSIZKAN Online Türk Sağlık Bilimleri Dergisi.2022; 7(3): 473. CrossRef
Purpose The present study aimed to identify the learning preferences of dental students and to characterize their relationship with academic performance at a dental school in Isfahan, Iran.
Methods This cross-sectional descriptive study included 200 undergraduate dental students from October to November 2016. Data were collected using a 2-part questionnaire. The first part included demographic data, and the second part was a Persian-language version of the visual, aural, read/write, and kinesthetic questionnaire. Data analysis was conducted with the chi-square test, 1-way analysis of variance, and multiple linear regression.
Results The response rate was 86.6%. Approximately half of the students (51.5%) had multimodal learning preferences. Among the unimodal group (48.5%), the most common mode was aural (24.0%), followed by kinesthetic (15.5%), reading-writing (8.0%), and visual (1.0%). There was a significant association between academic performance and the reading/writing learning style preference (P< 0.01).
Conclusion Multimodal learning styles were the most preferred. Among single-mode learning styles, the aural style was most common, followed by the kinesthetic style. Students with a reading/writing preference had better academic performance. The results of this study provide useful information for preparing a more problem-based curriculum with active learning strategies.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Eye-tracking insights into cognitive strategies, learning styles, and academic outcomes of Turkish medicine students Hande Argunsah, Levent Altıntaş, Melike Şahiner BMC Medical Education.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Preferred Learning Methods among First-year Medical Students: A Cross-Sectional Descriptive Study Gholamali Dehghani Depiction of Health.2024; 15(1): 27. CrossRef
Investigation of learning style patterns: A case study of basic sciences medical students at Tabriz University of Medical Sciences Gholamali Dehghani, Saeideh Ghaffarifar Journal of Medical Education Development.2024; 17(55): 75. CrossRef
Does learning style influence performance in objective structured clinical examinations? Anne-Cécile Ezanno, Florie Pirot, Julie Lavolé, Guillaume Le Gall, Raphaelle Mestiri, Charlotte Delattre, Sébastien Le Burel, Sandra Le Mener, Marie Gominet, Cécile Ficko, Hubert Nielly BMC Medical Education.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Learning styles vs. virtual education preferences: a cross-sectional study on medical sciences e-students Zahra Karimian, Zahra Zolfaghari Frontiers in Education.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Quantitative Evaluation of Dental Students’ Perceptions of the Roleplay-Video Teaching Modality in Clinical Courses of Dentistry: A Pilot Study Kiran Kumar Ganji, Anil Kumar Nagarajappa, Mohammed G Sghaireen, Kumar Chandan Srivastava, Mohammad Khursheed Alam, Shadi Nashwan, Ahmad Al-Qerem, Yousef Khader Healthcare.2023; 11(5): 735. CrossRef
Effectiveness of differentiated instruction on learning outcomes and learning satisfaction in the evidence‐based nursing course: Empirical research quantitative Shwu‐Ru Liou, Ching‐Yu Cheng, Tsui‐Ping Chu, Chia‐Hao Chang, Hsiu‐Chen Liu Nursing Open.2023; 10(10): 6794. CrossRef
Empowering individual learners: Call for promoting inclusivity among medical students with different learning styles Saurabh RamBihariLal Shrivastava, Novina Aryanti, Arief Wibawa Environmental Disease.2023; 8(3): 78. CrossRef
Unveiling the learning style puzzle: Factors that shape how medical students learn SaurabhRamBihariLal Shrivastava, DhiyaulAthifah M. Jasri Indian Journal of Health Sciences and Biomedical Research (KLEU).2023; 16(3): 435. CrossRef
Knowledge, attitude and practice of dentists toward providing care to the geriatric patients Bahareh Tahani, Skekoufeh Sedaghat Manesh BMC Geriatrics.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
The effect of learning style and general self-efficacy on satisfaction of e-Learning in dental students Tahereh Baherimoghadam, Shahram Hamedani, Manoosh mehrabi, Navid Naseri, Nooshin Marzban BMC Medical Education.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Identification of Preferred Learning Style of Medical and Dental Students Using VARK Questionnaire Ayesha Fahim, Saba Rehman, Fariha Fayyaz, Mariyah Javed, Muhammad Anwaar Alam, Sadia Rana, Fahim Haider Jafari, Mohammad Khursheed Alam, Mauro Henrique Nogueira Guimarães Abreu BioMed Research International.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Assessing the Students’ Perception of the Quality of Dental Program offered in Saudi Arabia Ahmed Al Kuwaiti The Open Dentistry Journal.2021; 15(1): 650. CrossRef
An Assessment of Learning Styles of Undergraduate Medical Students in Three Different Types of Curriculum Abdulrahman Alfawzan, Moeber Mahzari, Sajida Agha, Aamir Omair, Omar Alfawzan, Reema Alessa, Abdulaziz Alturki, Kholoud Alshiha Journal of Nature and Science of Medicine.2021; 4(3): 267. CrossRef
General Self-Efficacy and Self-Perceived Confidence of Dental Students in Performing Orthodontic Clinical Skills Shahla Momeni Danaei, Niloofar Azadeh, Dana Jafarpur Educational Research in Medical Sciences.2018;[Epub] CrossRef
Learning Style and Academic Achievement among Students at Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Iran Horyeh Sarbazvatan, Abolghasem Amini, Nayyereh Aminisani, SeyedMorteza Shamshirgaran, Saeideh Ghaffarifar Research and Development in Medical Education.2018; 7(2): 77. CrossRef